Business & Economy

The Hague court bans BYD Ti7 sales in EU over design infringement

A district court in The Hague ruled that the BYD Ti7 SUV infringes on Jaguar Land Rover designs, banning the vehicle from EU sales and production in Hungary. The ruling follows legal action by JLR after the Chinese automaker attempted to market the cheaper seven-seater model in the UK.

The Hague court bans BYD Ti7 sales in EU over design infringement

The Hague issues design ruling

The district court in The Hague ruled that the BYD Ti7 infringes the EU design of Jaguar Land Rover. This decision stops BYD from selling the seven-seater SUV in the EU, although the judge noted the court has no jurisdiction over BYD’s activities in the UK. The ban takes effect one week after Friday’s ruling. JLR launched legal action earlier this year after BYD announced it would take orders from UK customers for the vehicle on its website. Bailiffs acting for JLR recently seized digital records from BYD’s offices. The preliminary relief judge ruled that the Ti7 reflects the characteristic and distinctive elements of the design. I find the court’s decision that the Ti7 infringes the EU design of Jaguar Land Rover to be a decisive blow against the Chinese automaker.

Pricing gaps and production bans

Top Gear calls the plug-in hybrid SUV a "Chinese Defender clone." While the Ti7 has been on sale in China since last September, deliveries to UK customers are due from January 2027, and the vehicle costs £47,995, which is over £20,000 cheaper than the Defender. BYD’s website says the vehicle has an "unapologetically boxy profile" that delivers a "contemporary look."

Feature BYD Ti7 Land Rover Defender
Seats 7 7
UK Price £47,995 Over £67,995

JLR, owned by India’s Tata Motors, sold 29,500 Defenders to retail customers between July and September this year, an increase of more than 4,000 on the same period a year earlier. The seven-seat Defender remains one of the UK’s bestselling cars and is the company’s most popular model. JLR stated, "We protect our intellectual property and take legal action when necessary." BYD strongly disagrees with the ruling and says it will pursue every legal avenue to demonstrate the decision is incorrect. The court also banned BYD from producing the Ti7 at its new factory in Szeged, Hungary, which expects to begin production at the end of 2026, until the intellectual property case resolves. I find BYD’s attempt to market a cheaper imitation to be a blatant violation of design rights. JLR previously won a legal case to stop Jiangling Motors Corporation from selling a copycat vehicle in 2019 after a three-year court battle.