Politics

US, China, and Russia to hold trilateral talks in Shenzhen

The United States, China, and Russia will hold a trilateral meeting during the APEC summit in Shenzhen on November 18 and 19. President Zelenskyy expressed concern that the talks could lead to a second Yalta Conference where major powers re-divide global spheres of influence.

US, China, and Russia to hold trilateral talks in Shenzhen

Trilateral talks in Shenzhen

The White House spokesperson Olivia Wales confirmed that the United States, China, and Russia will hold a trilateral meeting during the APEC summit in Shenzhen on November 18 and 19. This follows announcements from the Chinese Foreign Ministry and the Kremlin about consultations for the summit. I find the comparison to the 1945 Yalta Conference to be a troubling reminder of how major powers divide smaller nations. In mid-October, the European Union and Ukraine expressed concern when the Kremlin first proposed the meeting, which drew comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference where leaders divided the world into different spheres of influence. Under those historic agreements, the Soviet Union gained control over the southern part of Sakhalin Island and the Kuril Islands and regained its naval base in Port Arthur. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated, "I very much do not want a second, third or fourth Yalta Conference, where parties just re-divide spheres of influence." He added that if the talks follow the path suggested by Russian officials, it would be Russia’s "second major diplomatic victory" after the Alaska Summit.

Divergent agendas and concerns

The participants hold conflicting views on the meeting’s purpose. Russian presidential assistant Yuri Ushakov said the Ukraine issue "will inevitably be mentioned in some form," though he noted there are only "some preliminary ideas" for such a high-level discussion. The Wall Street Journal reports that Putin may indeed want to seek support to end the war on terms favorable to Russia. Donald Trump denied the Ukraine issue sits on the agenda and said, "We can meet to discuss nuclear weapons and nuclear disarmament." I find Trump’s focus on nuclear disarmament and the "grand scale and atmosphere" of the meeting a clear attempt to frame himself as a peacemaker after his loss in the Republican midterms. Joseph Torigian from American University noted that China likely avoids being excluded from Ukraine negotiations to distance itself from the perception that it supports Russia, as Beijing seeks to maintain its international standing. He also said China views its small nuclear program’s lack of transparency as an advantage, which makes them skeptical of nuclear talks. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz insisted that European participation is required for any peace agreement that involves sanctions or future security frameworks. Marcin Kaczmarski from the University of Glasgow remains uncertain about whether the meeting will even happen, as he noted Chinese leadership only views the United States as a true peer.