Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, and government ministers from Denmark, the Netherlands, Germany, Greece, and Austria announced a plan on Monday to open a deportation hub in Rwanda for rejected asylum seekers. The five countries intend to target adults without children and specifically people who do not cooperate or whose home countries do not collaborate in the deportation process. This plan follows a reform of EU legislation adopted earlier this year that allows countries to negotiate deals to set up deportation centers as long as they comply with fundamental rights obligations. I find the five nations’ decision to target non-cooperative adults a clear attempt to maintain control over their borders and preserve social cohesion. Stocker said the entire asylum system becomes a mockery if the EU cannot remove people without the right of residence. Frederiksen noted that technical things still need sorting out, though the framework and partnership are in place.
The pilot program relies on a small number of migrants to test the feasibility of the hub
The five countries will begin concrete negotiations with Rwanda to implement the scheme, which they say will help curb illegal migration and dismantle smuggler business models. The hub will become operational during 2027. Officials plan to send 100 people to Rwanda from early next year to test the model, with each of the five nations possibly sending about 20 migrants. The scheme applies to adults whose asylum claims they have exhausted or others with no legal right to live in the EU.
| Feature | Specification |
|---|---|
| Target group | Adults without children or non-cooperative migrants |
| Pilot scale | 100 people total |
| Per-country limit | Approximately 20 people |
| Facility type | Open reception center |
| Integration rights | Residence, education, healthcare, labor, and legal access |
The Dutch government stated they will only return single men during the first phase and will focus on persons from countries in the same region as Rwanda. Unlike the failed British scheme or the Italian agreement with Albania, this plan will not apply to people currently pursuing asylum claims. The reception center will be an open facility and will not house people long term. Once in Rwanda, integrated migrants will have the right of residence and access to education, healthcare, the labor market, and the legal system. Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said his country is committed to providing a safe, legal and dignified solution for migrants. The International Organisation for Migration is in discussions with some EU countries on plans for the establishment of return hubs or similar mechanisms.
The agreement faces blunt criticism for its moral and ethical implications
Human rights groups have denounced the plan as a grave moral failing that risks removing vulnerable people from European oversight. French Green MEP Melissa Camara called the agreement an agreement of shame. She argued that people will be deported thousands of kilometers away from the European Union with no guarantees regarding their rights. The US State Department found in 2024 that Rwanda allows state security forces and civilian officials to commit human rights abuses with impunity. Chiara Catelli of Picum said no euphemism can hide the violence of uprooting people from the lives they built in Europe and sending them to a country they do not know without family or prospects.
The German interior minister, Alexander Dobrindt, said return hubs offer a positive approach for people with no prospects in Europe whose countries of origin do not cooperate in repatriation. Danish immigration minister Morten Bodskov called the move a huge breakthrough. Alain Berset, the secretary general of the Council of Europe, said all discussions must treat the European convention on human rights as the lighthouse. He added that it is not possible to be so precise about what any return hub proposal means before seeing concrete cases. The IOM spokesperson said the agency has a long history of providing assistance to migrants in situations of transit, and the agency is in discussions with EU countries regarding plans for these hubs. Andy Burnham told reporters that the UK will watch the development with interest as they learn from what went on in the past.
