Mayor intervenes to save magazine launch
Hackney mayor Zoe Garbett intervened to ensure a socialist magazine launch in East London proceeded on 4 November after Home Office officials pressured council staff to cancel the event. The meeting was a launch for the magazine Tribune, Britain’s oldest democratic socialist magazine, and included Andreas Malm via video link and Huda Ammori in person. Malm, the author of How to Blow Up a Pipeline, previously faced a UK travel ban because officials decided his presence was "not considered to be conducive to the public good." Garbett called the attempt to shut down the meeting an "appalling assault on free speech" and wrote to Shabana Mahmood to demand an explanation. The mayor asked how the Home Office reconciles its actions with the statutory obligations of local authorities to uphold free speech and peaceful assembly. A venue manager told Tribune the event had to be cancelled after Home Office concerns reached them, but Garbett, who was elected in May as the first Green party mayor in the UK, overruled this decision to protect local democratic values. Garbett ran on a pledge to protect progressive values against a Labour party that she says has enabled genocide abroad and eroded civil liberties at home.
Legal warnings from the Home Office
The Home Office warned Hackney council that the event could breach the Terrorism Act 2000, which makes it an offence to assist in arranging a meeting if the organiser knows it will be addressed by a person belonging to a proscribed organisation. Although the department’s own assessment said the event was "unlikely to meet the threshold for disruption," officials told Hackney council’s Prevent and hate-crime coordinator that Malm and Ammori were "two speakers of concern." This pressure followed an email on 12 October from the Home Office extremism disruptions team, which received a referral from a counter-extremism group regarding Malm. The team noted that Malm made statements in support of terrorists and direct action, particularly regarding Palestine and climate change. Ammori, the co-founder of Palestine Action, was challenging the group’s proscription in the Supreme Court on the same day as the talk. A Home Office official told the council that they could not direct the council to cancel the event, but they did ask if venue managers knew about the concerns regarding the speakers even if the talk was virtual. A Home Office spokesperson said it was "categorically untrue to suggest the Home Office pushed for this event to be cancelled," and maintained that the decision belonged to the council.
Speakers condemn censorship attempt
The speakers and the mayor rejected the government’s attempts to limit lawful political discussion. Malm said the UK’s crackdown on free expression is "terrifying" and accused the government of blocking people because they fear speech they disagree with. He also noted that the authorities first banned the books of Sally Rooney and then blocked people like him from entering the country. Ammori said the suggestion that her participation in a political discussion could make that discussion unlawful is "ludicrous." She noted that she has never been convicted of any crime, let alone a terrorism offence, and argued that the Home Office was misapplying the law to carry out unlawful acts of censorship. Ammori also said that the Home Office wrongly advised the council that this entirely lawful political discussion would breach the Terrorism Act simply because she was due to participate. Garbett argued that the Home Office’s attempt to censor legitimate discussion about Palestine shows a pattern of "petty authoritarianism" from the Labour government. The event in Hackney, a launch party for the magazine, proceeded with hundreds of people in attendance from the local area and beyond.
