Mathematical proof via Claude
Levent Alpoge, an Anthropic employee and mathematician, claims he used a non-public version of the Claude chatbot to create a 250,000-line proof of the Riemann hypothesis. He developed the proof over six weeks. The mathematician announced the finding on Friday, one day after Anthropic made its US stock market debut. Alpoge sent a message to Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei on Sunday asking how he could announce the discovery. He told reporters, "The precise timing is horrible," and stated, "I am clearly unilaterally responsible for feeling I just could not live if I waited even longer." Alpoge described the discovery as "one dawn across science of something far greater." This nearly 170-year-old problem, named for Bernhard Riemann, suggests that prime numbers have a determined order along the number line. Because prime numbers are the bedrock of higher maths, breakthroughs in this area have broad impact. He submitted the complete proof in Lean, a computer language used for confirming maths proofs.
Verification and academic skepticism
Terrance Tao, a mathematician, said on Friday that verification of the proof is still some way off. "I imagine the digestion process will take some time, though in this case at least we have a human author to communicate with to assist this task," Tao said. This claim follows a September announcement from OpenAI. The company used 10,000 AI agents to solve part of the notoriously difficult Navier-Stokes equations in 88 hours. OpenAI deployed these autonomous computer programmed bots as part of an AI training exercise. The Navier-Stokes proof remains unconfirmed. This solution set off criticism within academic and higher maths communities regarding the use of AI to solve maths problems.
A group of maths scholars sent a letter stating that when AI companies claim major solutions to show how sophisticated their commercial products have become, it is "detrimental to the science of mathematics." These scholars wrote, "We are witnessing a general threat to intellectual work, with misalignment between the outcome of the use of AI and its initial purpose." OpenAI released what it claimed were solutions, proofs, or major progress on 372 more outstanding higher maths problems a month after its Navier-Stokes claim. Experts will take months, if not longer, to review those claims to prove their validity.
