Legal conflict in Berlin
Alexander Zverev received formal notification of a lawsuit from his former partner, Brenda Patea, on Wednesday during the ATP Finals in Turin. Patea, the mother of Zverev’s daughter, filed a civil complaint in Berlin following an interview the tennis player gave to the French newspaper L’Equipe in June. This lawsuit targets Zverev’s claim that "my innocence has been proven" after his Grand Slam victories this year. Patea’s lawyer, Michael Scheele, said that Zverev’s claim over his innocence "triggered a veritable storm of criticism against our client" and that the backlash was damaging to her business as an influencer because she is a content creator. He also stated that Patea felt her honour had been violated by these comments. Both Patea and Zverev had agreed to make no public statements in their settlement. I find his attempt to publicly declare his innocence a direct violation of the quiet agreement he signed to resolve the 2020 bodily harm charge. Zverev, the player who ascended to the world No 1 ranking this month, has not commented on the lawsuit.
| Case Details | Information |
|---|---|
| Lawsuit location | Berlin, Germany |
| Maximum fine per violation | €250,000 (£209,000) |
| Settlement date | June 2024 |
| Original charge date | May 2020 |
Legal defense and history
The legal dispute stems from a May 2020 incident in Berlin where Zverev faced a charge of causing bodily harm to Patea. Zverev always denied the charges. The criminal proceedings in Berlin ended in June 2024 after both parties reached an out-of-court settlement. The court told the BBC that the decision was not a verdict and it was not a decision about guilt or innocence. However, the court also noted that the defendant agreed to the termination of the case and the witness expressed a wish to end the trial. Patea’s lawyer, Michael Scheele, said that Zverev was neither found guilty nor acquitted, and the settlement prevented him from talking about the case. He also said that Zverev made a payment for the daughter, but he made nothing for Patea. Patea seeks an injunction to prevent Zverev from repeating these claims and requests fines of up to €250,000 (£209,000) for every violation. This civil complaint was filed in Berlin in September. Zverev’s lawyers, Christian Schertz and Anna Sophie Heuchemer, say they will defend him. They argue the statement constitutes a "permissible expression of opinion" protected by Article 5(1) of the German Basic Law. They also claim Zverev only expressed his personal conviction that he did everything in his power to refute the allegations during the proceedings. They noted that the criminal proceedings were discontinued without any finding of guilt, and the presumption of innocence remains unaffected. Zverev previously told BBC Sport, "That’s what dropping the case is. That is innocence." He also told reporters that they are not going to drop the case if you are guilty and that he wants to move on.
