The removal request and Google’s response
Google declined a request from the Prison Service of England and Wales to remove a YouTube video featuring Russell Brand, who serves a 10.5-year prison sentence following his conviction for rape and three counts of sexual assault. Laura Brand, the wife of the comedian, posted the video on Sunday, which contains a message where Brand claims, "I am not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for." The Prison Service formally requested the removal through an established mechanism used with tech companies because they believe the content offends Brand’s victims and reached a substantial audience. Google told BBC News that its teams are investigating the new content but maintained that its rules had not been broken. The company suspended Brand’s channel from the YouTube Partner Program in September 2023, which prevents him from monetising content on the platform.
The Ministry of Justice told the BBC that asking for the removal of content that remains "distressing for victims" seemed "only right." While the department believes YouTube should remove the video, the platform maintains that its own terms dictate whether to take content down.
Political reactions to the video
Housing minister Matthew Pennycook described the video as "abhorrent" and said the government remains in "close dialogue" with Google. While the Ministry of Justice believes YouTube should remove the content because it remains "distressing for victims," Jess Phillips told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme that the government "doesn’t have the power to enforce that this video is taken down." Phillips, describing Brand as an "absolute narcissist," suggested the government might look to introduce a second online safety act to address gaps in current regulatory frameworks. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch stated she would not immediately demand Google remove the video if she held power, arguing that YouTube is a private platform where demanding content removal without verifying a law was broken is not where she would start. Children’s minister Josh MacAlister told the Today programme that Meta’s decision to disable Brand’s other accounts provides a clear template for taking action, adding that Google should remove the video.
| Platform | Status of Brand’s Account | Policy/Reason |
|---|---|---|
| YouTube | Active; no monetization | Suspended from Partner Program in September 2023 |
| Disabled | Policy against accounts run by convicted sex offenders | |
| Disabled | Policy against accounts run by convicted sex offenders | |
| Disabled | Policy against accounts run by convicted sex offenders | |
| X | Active | No specific restriction mentioned |
Prison rules and victim allegations
Justice Secretary Alex Norris is investigating whether Brand breached prison rules by issuing the statement. Downing Street called the message "clearly appalling" and noted that prisoners face strict bans on making statements that cause distress to victims. Speaking on the issue, the government stated that speaking to the media only receives permission in exceptional circumstances. If the investigation finds Brand violated regulations, he faces repercussions like a temporary phone ban or live monitoring of his calls. This scenario resembles a 2022 instance where inmate Charles Bronson faced phone restrictions after he sent an unauthorised audio message to Sky News regarding his bid for parole.
Mia Latter, 37, who alleged she was raped by Brand when she was 16, told the Today programme she found the message shared by the couple during their Sunday Service show "upsetting." She expressed being appalled by the "Christian message alongside absolute lies" and noted that Brand denies her claims. She remains one of the women who made allegations against Brand in 2023 following an investigation by the Times, Sunday Times, and Channel 4’s Dispatches. Brand’s X account remains active, where a message appeared on 11 November regarding Meta’s decision to disable his Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp accounts. That message stated, "There was never a Russell Brand, according to @meta," and added, "Thank God for @elonmusk" before concluding, "Stay tuned."
