Diplomatic stalling
I find the decision to postpone formal treaty negotiations until 2028 a massive failure. The final decision proposes to "elaborate" an instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems in the context of international humanitarian law. This shift occurred after Ireland, Brazil, Belgium, and Austria watered down their positions because they feared "leaving the conference empty-handed," according to a Brazilian diplomat. Two EU diplomats identified the U.S., the U.K., South Korea, Japan, Turkey, and Israel as nations resisting binding regulation. France called for a "hybrid document" containing both non-binding and binding elements, while Germany advocated for an "international instrument" rather than a legally binding protocol.
| Interest Group | Specific Countries or Entities |
|---|---|
| Resisting binding regulation | U.S., U.K., South Korea, Japan, Turkey, Israel |
| Pushing for regulation | Ireland, Brazil, Belgium, Austria |
| Proposing hybrid elements | France |
| Advocating international instrument | Germany |
Disappointing technology gap
The conference outcome requires a group of intergovernmental experts to report conclusions to a 2028 meeting of countries party to the treaty. This delay leaves the world vulnerable as AI and automation transform warfare. Verity Coyle, the deputy director for arms at Human Rights Watch, said this outcome is disappointing because the technology is racing ahead. I agree that the decision fails to provide the urgent action needed to agree new rules. Rain Liivoja, a director with the Asia-Pacific Institute for Law and Security, said it remains possible, even likely, that there will be no treaty by the end of 2028 because the decision contains no mention of a legally binding instrument. Civil society groups said the conference fell short of expectations. I find the decision to skip a legally binding instrument entirely as a way to satisfy countries like the U.S., the U.K., and Israel. The intergovernmental experts must report to a 2028 meeting, a delay that I believe serves the interests of those resisting regulation more than those seeking to control lethal autonomous systems. I see the decision to postpone these talks as a setback for the regulation of autonomous weapons.
