A stalemate in Turkey
Negotiations in Antalya reached a standstill on Saturday night because a coalition of 130 countries wants to include a reference to the "transition away from fossil fuels" in the final agreement. Saudi Arabia and other oil-rich nations oppose an explicit statement on fossil fuel use. This delay forces the dual presidency of Australia’s Chris Bowen and Turkey’s Murat Kurum to manage meetings into Sunday. I find this dual presidency, split between two countries with little tradition in climate diplomacy, a failure that weakens the whole process. The third draft of the potential headline agreement, released in the early hours on Sunday, attempted to address the impasse by recalling the deal reached in Dubai three years ago when countries first reached consensus on moving away from coal, oil, and gas.
Maina Talia, the climate minister for the low-lying Pacific island Tuvalu, says the inclusion of a reference to fossil fuels is a red line for her nation. She claims that without it, the meeting wastes time. Mohamed Adow, director of the Power Shift Africa thinktank, says rich countries spent two weeks finding reasons not to deliver the financial support they promised. He says the meeting feels like it is unravelling. He also notes that governments are retreating from promises they have already made.
CCS targets and the possible showdown
Disagreements also persist regarding controversial carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology. Saudi Arabia wants strong recommendations of CCS in the cover decision, but other countries object because they see this technology as a way to perpetuate the fossil fuel industry. The third draft removed a hard target for CCS and notes that as much electrification as possible must be powered by clean energy. Other delegates worry that focusing on CCS allows the industry to bypass actual emission reductions.
| Topic | Detail/Target |
|---|---|
| Electrification Target | 35% of world energy from electricity by 2035 |
| CCS Status | Hard target removed from third draft |
| Decision Type | Cover decision |
The inclusion of a reference to fossil fuels came after the EU, the UK, many African countries, and the world’s least developed countries joined together on Saturday evening to march to the presidency office. These small island states, which are among the most vulnerable to the climate crisis, demanded the reinstatement of the reference. Harjeet Singh, the global convener of the Fill the Fund campaign, says developing countries cannot change their economies while they are drowning in disasters and debt. He says the failure of this Cop in Antalya stems from a lack of money and a lack of will from those who caused this crisis. Nick Dearden, director of the campaign group Global Justice Now, says fossil fuel interests hold the world to ransom.
One possible next step involves forcing an open meeting to compel Saudi Arabia and its allies to state their opposition to the stronger outcome publicly. This move could cause the talks to collapse. Bill Hare, chief executive of the Climate Analytics thinktank, says if the overwhelming number of countries here want a strong text referencing the transition away from fossil fuels and so on and Saudi Arabia is on its own, Saudi Arabia will probably not stand against the global consensus. China and India, though not part of the 130-country progressive coalition, are also unlikely to stand against a deal. Miatta Fahnbulleh, the UK energy minister, says discussions remain productive and a deal exists to be done.
