A strategy for doomsday resilience
Estonia plans to run its government from the cloud if Russian forces occupy its territory. Tonu Grunberg, an architect of this "doomsday resilience" strategy and the current CEO of Levira, says officials want to move public services to the cloud when data centers are destroyed or there are "boots on the ground and we cannot operate." This strategy aims to keep all critical services online regardless of what happens on the ground for the country of 1.3 million people. Estonia already maintains a data backup in its digital embassy in Luxembourg that contains citizen registries, land registries, and its legal code. The Estonian government is building secure applications on cloud providers including Microsoft Azure and Amazon Web Services as well as its own state cloud platform while shipping the system to its data embassy and other places in Europe. I find this move to delocalize infrastructure a logical response to the risk of physical data center destruction.
Minimizing the impact of conflict
Allan Allmere, an adviser for IT architecture and infrastructure at the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs, says the country wants to minimize the impact of the worst-case scenario. He notes that while no country can predict every risk, Estonia must preserve a trusted foundation to prevent the state from having to start again from zero. This planning comes as nations like the United Kingdom and Norway discuss hosting each others’ secure data through their own "data embassies." I believe the reliance on providers like Microsoft and Amazon creates a new vulnerability, as the Microsoft outage last week showed how technical failures can disrupt services worldwide. The threat to digital infrastructure is real. Last month, Ukraine struck three data centers belonging to the Russian provider Yandex, showing how targeting compute power is like striking a power plant. Estonia shares a 294-kilometer border with Russia and faces risks from cyberattacks, arson plots, and cuts to undersea data cables. Authorities described the 2007 incident as a large-scale modern cyberattack targeting a country. Joseph Jarnecki, a senior research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, says Estonia is taking a "forward-leaning approach" through investments in partnerships with safe third countries rather than keeping everything physically under its own territorial control. Allmere says the first priority was preventing state data from disappearing, but the next challenge involves ensuring the state can continue functioning with that data during a crisis. He also says Tallinn must ensure the same data remains understandable and usable many decades from now.
