Polymarket and Kalshi now host bets on US measles outbreaks and other health crises. Users wager on when the FDA approves a skin-cancer vaccine or if the CDC changes vaccine recommendations. Markets also allow bets on how many measles cases the US sees in 2026 and if the country loses its measles-elimination status this year. A sign in Brooklyn displayed a Polymarket logo next to a message that asked, "Will any state end vaccine markets?" Matthew Eisenberg, professor and chair of health policy and management at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, says the companies will list contracts on anything with a checkable outcome.
Prediction markets position themselves as financial derivatives to operate under federal commodities laws with oversight from the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission. This classification allows them to bypass state regulations that govern traditional gambling, though several states have filed lawsuits alleging these companies function as gambling sites. Lia Nower, a professor and the director of the Center for Gambling Studies at Rutgers University, says gambling is like the "wild, wild west" because no federal regulatory body prescribes limits or minimum guidelines for states to follow. There are no research centers at the National Institutes of Health focused on gambling like those for alcohol or drug abuse.
| Market Focus | Possible Outcome |
|---|---|
| FDA Decisions | Vaccine or drug approval |
| CDC Policy | Vaccine recommendation changes |
| Clinical Trials | Drug trial results |
| Public Officials | Agency staff resignations |
Predictions on FDA decisions and trial endpoints create a payoff for anyone with nonpublic information, such as agency reviewers, trial investigators, legislative staff, or health officials, says Eisenberg. Trial participants could purposefully change their behavior to affect outcomes, and drug companies could change the timing of trials. Eisenberg says the risk is not necessarily that a reviewer takes a bribe, but that the market rewards leaks. Dani Lever, a spokesperson for Kalshi, says these markets improve transparency because the people who best know if a trial succeeds are scattered and their insight rarely reaches the public.
Problem gambling is a growing public health issue that disproportionately affects young, Black, Hispanic, and lower-income people. Lia Nower co-authored a report showing more than half of young people between the ages of 13 and 27 gambled in the past year. Among those young gamblers, 39.5% had some degree of gambling-related risk and 10.3% were high risk for problem gambling. Matthew Eisenberg found that legalization leads to measurable increases in treatment for depression and anxiety among young men. Because prediction markets sit outside traditional state-level consumer protections, Eisenberg says these products have exited the only regulatory system designed to limit gambling harm.
New Jersey is moving to restrict these markets to protect consumers and prevent people with inside information from profiting from event contracts. Eisenberg notes that low-value contracts, such as a few-hundred-dollar contract on the childhood vaccine schedule, do not reflect public opinion because a single trader can move the price. He says there have been discussions to create state-level consumer protections, like deposit limits, self-exclusion, rules about advertising, and funding for treatment paid out of state betting taxes, but prediction markets sit outside all of that. Within a week, the Polymarket sign in Brooklyn was vandalized and the bottom portion containing the logo and the text about placing predictions was ripped away.
