Politics

Geneva talks on autonomous weapons treaty end in stalemate

Negotiations for a legally binding international treaty to control autonomous weapons collapsed in Geneva after Russian objections prevented consensus. While over 100 states pushed for new laws, the conference adopted a weak mandate that may lack any legal obligations.

Geneva talks on autonomous weapons treaty end in stalemate

Geneva talks end in stalemate

The week-long efforts to agree a negotiating mandate for a legally binding international treaty to control the use of autonomous weapons collapsed just before 5am on Saturday morning. All night talks failed to overcome Russian objections, as diplomats reported that Russia used stalling tactics from the opening day. While more than 100 states pushed for a new law, the requirement for consensus among the 128 parties to the convention forced the conference to adopt a weak mandate to "elaborate by consensus." This instrument may not carry any legal obligations at all. I consider this a total failure of diplomacy since states have discussed the dangers of these weapons for 13 years. Max Tegmark, the chair of the Future of Life Institute, said that "slaughterbots are already here" and that states agreed it is sufficient to just talk about this for the 14th year.

AI warfare expands

Defense technology powers including South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the UK, France, and Germany resisted being bound by a new law and instead advocated for a nonbinding agreement. The US said the need for human control over autonomous weapons was discussed in meetings between president Xi Jinping and Donald Trump this week, but the US was reluctant to agree to a binding treaty. I find the US five-year proposal for a mandate obstructive, especially since Bonnie Docherty noted that treaties can be negotiated within 15 months.

Bloc of Seven pushing for binding treaty
Austria
Belgium
Brazil
Ireland
Mexico
New Zealand
Panama

Brazil’s delegate told the floor on Wednesday that these weapons are not weapons of the future but are already in use and being further developed. The military reality is much faster than the diplomatic process. The Pentagon struck more than 1,000 targets in Iran on the first day of the war, and investigative media reports say the US military aims to carry out 1,000 AI-assisted targeting decisions per hour. During the final day of the conference, the Egyptian delegation shouted at the conference chair to protest the exclusion of several nonmember countries from the negotiations. Former US national security adviser John Bolton told an Atlantic magazine conference that "the boundaries western civilisation tried to draw between war and civilian life are disintegrating."