Politics

Supreme Court declines to hear appeal blocking DEI grant cancellations

The Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal against a lower court decision that prevents the government from canceling grants for seven California researchers. The ruling maintains an injunction against the termination of DEI-related funding, which a court found violated the First Amendment.

Supreme Court declines to hear appeal blocking DEI grant cancellations

Injunction protects California researchers

On Monday, the Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal of a lower court decision that blocks the government from canceling the grants of seven researchers in California. This ruling prevents the government from continuing its purge of DEI-related work initiated during the Trump administration. The lawsuit, initially filed by researchers at the University of California, Berkeley and UC San Francisco, contested grants issued by various federal agencies, ranging from the National Institutes of Health to the Department of Transportation, after they were terminated following a Trump executive order. These researchers argued that the agencies terminated their funding because they decided the grants violated a Trump executive order blocking the use of DEI, even though the administration never defined DEI and used keyword searches to identify targets. While the case now focuses on seven researchers, the District Court’s ruling that the government’s actions violated the First Amendment may have broad implications. The researchers argued that the cancellations were viewpoint discrimination that violated the First Amendment, a claim the District Court agreed with when it issued a preliminary injunction to restore the funds. This decision effectively maintains the injunction that would restore the grants to the targeted researchers.

The scope of the litigation narrowed to agencies such as the Environmental Protection Agency, the National Science Foundation, and the National Endowment for the Humanities because a previous Supreme Court decision held that most grant termination cases must be heard by different courts. A Court of Appeals panel upheld the preliminary injunction that would restore the grants to these seven researchers. The panel ruled that while the government has the option of eliminating grant programs it determines are no longer appropriate, canceling individual grants it disagrees with is an attempt at "suppression of dangerous ideas." The court cited Supreme Court precedent regarding religious viewpoint discrimination in support of this finding. The court ruled that DEI fits this framework because it "convey[s] the viewpoint that the exclusion of historically disadvantaged groups is undesirable." The government terminated individual grants in existing programs based on the perceived viewpoints of individual speakers instead of merely exercising its power to choose which programs to fund. The Supreme Court provided no discussion of its rejection and no justices filed a dissent. This lack of intervention is a blunt sign that the government’s anti-DEI efforts are on shaky legal ground.